Game day
Michigan vs. Villanova
Rapid reactions to Michigan’s 79-73 road loss to Villanova.
The Moment
After giving up a turnover early in the second half, Trey McKenney streaked down the court and uncharacteristically lost his cool. Putting two hands on a Villanova player without the ball, McKenney shoved the player through the baseline.
Consequently, he was assessed for a flagrant one. The Wildcats made both of the free throws, extending their lead to double digits for the first time of the night. McKenney wasn’t the only player who struggled with mental decisions — but his was the ugliest of the night. Villanova took those gifts with open arms and marched to their victory, extending its lead to as many as 17 points midway through the second half.
When the Wolverines climbed back into the game late, another flagrant foul on McKenney stopped the comeback short. Villanova appealed a Devin Royal foul that would have given McKenney two free throws to cut the deficit to 4 points with 1:15 to play, and the referees ruled McKenney committed a hook-and-hold—a costly 4-point swing in the final 90 seconds.
The Takeaway
Michigan’s night was marked by an air of carelessness. Struggling with both turnovers and fouls, the Wolverines lost themselves the game more than Villanova won it.
Turnovers cost Michigan 10 points in the first half, nearly a third of Villanova points up to that point. Fouls sidelined JP Estrella and Elliot Cadeau early in the second half, forcing Michigan to rely on Oscar Goodman to play the four and for Trey McKenney to run the point. With six minutes left, Estrella, Cadeau, and Thiam all had four fouls.
It wasn’t just all defensive fouls, though, the Wolverines constantly limited their opportunities with off-arm fouls on the other side of the floor or moving screens.
Despite playing incredibly sloppily for the first 35 minutes, the Wolverines seemingly figured it out with five minutes left, getting within four points of Villanova. Still, this final stretch was more the exception than the rule.
The Star
Despite the ugly start to the second half, McKenney’s early play suggested the sophomore was taking a second-year jump.
Trey McKenney has gone through slight growing pains as he’s been asked to be a first option on offense. First halves especially have been fraught for the sophomore, with the majority — or sometimes all — of his scoring coming in the second half. Against Villanova, no such wait was needed. McKenney nearly matched the rest of the starters’ total points, scoring 11 to their 15.
McKenney made most of his success in the first half from beyond the arc, hitting three 3-pointers on just five attempts. In the second half, McKenney went 2-for-6 from beyond the arc, while adding in a layup and trips to the line for a total 11 second-half points.
He was the bright spot for the Wolverines on offense, finishing with 22 points on 7-of-17 shooting.
The Stat
Michigan entered the matchup averaging 12.5 turnovers per game. After 25 minutes of play, they racked up 13, before ending the night with 16, a 23% turnover rate.
The biggest issue was that so many of the turnovers were easily preventable. In just the first half: A post-up from JP Estrella turned into a travel, Kenny Noland dribbled out a shot clock, not aware of the time ticking down, and Roddy Gayle Jr. threw a lob to no one as Moustapha Thiam didn’t see the ball coming in.
Villanova capitalized on these errors, scoring 18 points off the turnovers, with many becoming simple layups or dunks within the paint.
Four Factors

More from this game
- RecapGame 5: Michigan at Villanova Recap
- Five TakeawaysComing soon
- Report CardComing soon
- What they saidEvery postgame interview and quote in the Locker Room
- Photo galleryPhoto Gallery: Villanova 79, Michigan 73
The game thread 568 replies · most liked
- SpikeNovak Hartman dressed and warming with a shoulder brace♥ 9
- umhoops And I’m sure everyone is going to be dialed in to the hoops and not the end of the football game!♥ 9
- CoryR Can we stop referring to Roddy as “Ohio State transfer”? I prefer, “National Champion Roddy Gayle.”♥ 7
- MichiganMan2424 Thiam making his first 3 in a game feels like it may end up being a bad thing long term♥ 7
- DMB43 Feels like the biggest road game of the Mike Boynton tenure!♥ 6
Join the conversation · 6 replies on the forum
The conversation
6 repliesJoin the discussionJD1
Plenty of room for growth. I hope that Hartman fits into the equation as a contributor and that Noland becomes a lot more than he’s been so far.
ChathaM1
How rare is it for a team to win the eFG% battle but lose the game?
DMB43
2025 Michigan probably did that in every loss lol
MTung
Digging the huge hole on the road was preventable, and other words that could get me banned, but the end of the game run showed character and is something to build upon moving forward.
ChathaM1
For anyone who cares, AI says the team with the highest eFG% wins 80-85% of the time.